Cash N Gold logo

Cash N Gold in Milwaukee, WI

3.9/5

Greater Milwaukee Coin buys and sells gold, rare coins, and jewelry across Wisconsin. Founded in 1987, they're members of major numismatic organizations.

Data compiled from public sources · Rating from CreditDoc methodology

Cash N Gold Review

Greater Milwaukee Coin was established in 1987 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and has built a reputation as a trusted dealer in precious metals and numismatic items. The company operates as a buyer and seller of gold, rare coins, and jewelry, serving the greater Milwaukee area with a physical location in Brookfield.

The company offers gold purchasing services for customers looking to sell gold items, rare coin acquisition and sales for collectors, jewelry buying, and antique coin dealing. They position themselves as a one-stop location for both selling precious metals and purchasing specialty coins. Their services cater to both casual sellers and serious collectors.

Greater Milwaukee Coin distinguishes itself through extensive professional affiliations, including membership in the American Numismatic Association, Professional Numismatic Guild, Better Business Bureau, PCGS, and NGC—among others. They actively participate in rare coin shows and conventions nationwide, indicating ongoing engagement with the numismatic community. This level of organizational involvement suggests expertise and commitment to industry standards.

The company operates limited hours (10am-5pm weekdays, 10am-2pm Saturdays) from a single Brookfield location. While their professional credentials are strong, potential customers should note the limited accessibility and geographic concentration of their physical presence. The website provides basic contact information but limited detail about pricing, appraisal processes, or specific terms for transactions.

Services & Features

Antique coin dealing and sales
Attendance at regional and national coin shows for inventory acquisition
Coins certified through PCGS and NGC
Gold buying and purchasing from customers
Jewelry buying
Numismatic expertise and consultation
Professional coin appraisal services
Rare coin sales to collectors

Feature Checklist

Mobile App
Online Portal
Score Tracking
Credit Education
Personal Advisor
Identity Theft Protection

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Member of American Numismatic Association and Professional Numismatic Guild, indicating professional credibility
  • BBB membership provides third-party accountability and dispute resolution
  • 35+ years in business (founded 1987) demonstrates longevity and market trust
  • Active participation in rare coin shows and conventions nationwide
  • Dual services: both gold/jewelry buying and rare coin sales in one location
  • Membership in PCGS and NGC—major coin certification bodies
  • Multiple professional affiliations (Central States, Numismatists of Wisconsin, local coin clubs)

Cons

  • Limited hours (weekdays 10am-5pm, Saturdays 10am-2pm only) restrict access
  • Single physical location in Brookfield limits geographic accessibility for broader Wisconsin market
  • Website provides no pricing information, appraisal process details, or transaction terms
  • No mention of authentication guarantees, return policies, or buyer protections
  • Minimal online presence or ability to conduct transactions remotely

Rating Breakdown

Value
5.0
Effectiveness
3.5
Customer Service
3.5
Transparency
3.5
Ease of Use
3.9

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Cash N Gold legitimate?

Yes. Cash N Gold is a registered company, headquartered in 954 N 27th St, Milwaukee, WI 53208.

Quick Facts

Headquarters
954 N 27th St, Milwaukee, WI 53208
BBB Accredited
No
Starting Price
Contact provider
Setup Fee
None
Money-Back Guarantee
No
Visit Cash N Gold

CreditDoc Diagnosis

Doctor's Verdict on Cash N Gold

Greater Milwaukee Coin is best suited for established coin collectors and Milwaukee-area residents with precious metals or rare coins to sell, or collectors seeking authenticated coins. The main caveat is limited accessibility—single location, restricted hours, and no online transaction capability make them inconvenient for most Wisconsin consumers outside Brookfield.

Best For

  • Collectors and enthusiasts seeking to buy rare coins and numismatic items from a credentialed dealer
  • Milwaukee-area residents looking to sell gold, jewelry, or coins to an established local buyer
  • Serious numismatists requiring professional-grade coins certified by PCGS or NGC
Updated 2026-04-29

More Pawn Shops

W

We Buy Everything Pawn Shop - Springfield

0.0/5
Contact BBB:

Financial Wellness Guides

Affiliate Disclosure: CreditDoc may earn a commission when you click links to Cash N Gold and other services. These commissions help us maintain our free research. Our editorial team independently evaluates all services. Compensation does not influence our ratings or rankings. Learn more.