Advance America
Category: emergency cash
BBB Rating: A+
Oklahoma City, OK Advance America at 9300 N May Ave offers payday and title loans to local residents.
Read the full Advance America review →Comparison research for the "advance america vs ace cash express" query.
Both Advance America and ACE Cash Express offer payday loans with A+ BBB ratings and same-day funding, but differ significantly in reach and consumer protections. Advance America operates 800+ branches across 27 states with payday APRs of 143.29%-688.28%, while ACE Cash Express has 900+ locations in 23 states with payday APRs typically exceeding 300%. ACE's 72-hour satisfaction guarantee is stronger than Advance America's job-loss protection. However, Advance America's broader geographic availability and slightly lower APR floor make it marginally preferable for borrowers in available states, though both remain expensive short-term lending options.
Category: emergency cash
BBB Rating: A+
Oklahoma City, OK Advance America at 9300 N May Ave offers payday and title loans to local residents.
Read the full Advance America review →Category: emergency cash
BBB Rating: A+
Terrytown, LA's ACE Cash Express at 624 Terry Pkwy offers fast payday and title loans.
Read the full ACE Cash Express review →Advance America offers broader geographic coverage (27 vs 23 states), a lower payday APR floor (143.29% vs 300%+), and more diverse loan products including lines of credit. While ACE's 72-hour satisfaction guarantee is compelling, Advance America's superior APR range and physical presence in more states provide better accessibility and value for emergency borrowers.
| Field | Advance America | ACE Cash Express |
|---|---|---|
| Category | emergency cash | emergency cash |
| BBB Rating | A+ | A+ |
| Google Rating | — | — |
| Headquarters | Spartanburg, SC | Irving, TX |
| Founded | 1997 | 1968 |
| Website | View | View |
The comparison table above uses the fields both providers publish on their CreditDoc profile. Empty fields ("—") mean the provider has not disclosed that field or the field has not yet been verified by CreditDoc research. Every field on each profile links to the underlying source where available; every rating is the stored public value at time of check. Verify pricing, refund policy, and licensing directly with the provider before signing anything based on this comparison.
This is a research starting point, not a recommendation. Comparison pages on CreditDoc summarize the publicly-listed fields from two provider profiles side by side. That is useful for spotting differences on price, licensing, refund policy, and public review signals — but it is not a recommendation that one provider is "better" than the other in absolute terms. Which provider fits you depends on your credit situation, the specific service you need, the state you live in, and the pricing tier that matches your budget.
Confirm pricing in writing before signing with either provider. The summary above reflects the pricing published on each provider's website at the time of the last CreditDoc check. Providers can and do change pricing without notifying comparison sites first. If either Advance America or ACE Cash Express quotes a rate to you over the phone that differs from the number on their public site, ask them to send the confirmed price in writing before you sign — that is your CROA-protected right in every US state.
Cross-check both providers in the CFPB Consumer Complaint Database. At consumerfinance.gov/data-research/consumer-complaints, search both Advance America and ACE Cash Express by name. Look for the total complaint count, the resolution rate, and the pattern of issue categories (billing disputes, misleading claims, customer service). Both companies may be in the database; the pattern of resolutions is more useful than raw complaint volume, since larger providers naturally attract more complaints.
Verify state licensing. Both Advance America and ACE Cash Express should hold active licenses in the state where you plan to use their services. Check the state's Department of Financial Services website for the current licensing status. Providers that are licensed in some states but not others may not be able to offer their advertised pricing to you.
Public review signals include BBB rating, Google rating with a review count, and the pattern of complaints in the CFPB Consumer Complaint Database. Above, the CreditDoc profile shows each provider's stored public rating and review count where available. A higher rating with a larger review count is a more reliable signal than a very high rating with only a handful of reviews. Cross-reference both providers in the CFPB Consumer Complaint Database at consumerfinance.gov/data-research/consumer-complaints — a pattern of unresolved complaints against either Advance America or ACE Cash Express is a strong signal to keep researching alternatives.
Licensing varies by state. Both Advance America and ACE Cash Express should hold an active license in the state where you plan to use their services — check the state's Department of Financial Services (or equivalent agency) for the current status. A provider that is licensed in one state may not be licensed to serve consumers in another. If either provider cannot give you their state license number in writing, that is a red flag — for credit repair providers, the Credit Repair Organizations Act (CROA) also requires a written contract with a three-day cancellation window regardless of state.
CreditDoc may earn a commission when a consumer clicks a provider link and signs up. That commission does not determine whether Advance America or ACE Cash Express appears in this comparison, does not determine the winner selection above, and does not determine what star rating either provider carries. The comparison is based on publicly-listed fields (pricing, licensing, refund policy, public review signals) — the same fields you would collect yourself if you called each provider directly. See the affiliate disclosure below.
Ask the provider to send the confirmed pricing in writing. That is your CROA-protected right in every US state. Providers can and do change pricing without notifying comparison sites first, so pricing shown on this page reflects the value at the time of the last CreditDoc check. If the number quoted to you is materially different, ask for a written price disclosure before signing. If either provider refuses to disclose pricing in writing, treat that as a strong signal to compare with an alternative.
Affiliate Disclosure: CreditDoc may earn a commission when you click links to products and services featured on this page. Compensation does not determine whether a provider can be covered or how visible star ratings are calculated. Learn more.