Fidelis Catholic logo

Fidelis Catholic

4.1/5

Fidelis Care is a health insurance provider offering Medicaid Managed Care, Medicare Advantage, and Qualified Health Plans across New York and other states.

Data compiled from public sources · Rating from CreditDoc methodology

Fidelis Catholic Review

Fidelis Care is a health insurance company that provides comprehensive coverage options for individuals and families at different life stages and income levels. The organization operates as a managed care provider under the Centene Corporation umbrella, offering multiple plan types including Medicaid Managed Care, Medicare Advantage, Essential Plan, Child Health Plus, and Qualified Health Plans (ACA marketplace plans). The company serves New York residents primarily and has expanded to include programs like Fidelis Care at Home for long-term managed care and WellCare partnerships for Medicare beneficiaries.

Fidelis Care's service offerings include access to a broad provider network, prescription drug coverage, preventive care benefits, and telemedicine services. Their Qualified Health Plans feature 24/7 telemedicine with $0 copay, wellness rewards programs, and fitness reimbursements. Medicare Advantage plans include supplemental benefits such as dental, vision, hearing coverage, and the WellCare Spendables debit card for out-of-pocket health expenses. The Essential Plan offers $0 premium coverage with free preventive care and dental/vision benefits for eligible New Yorkers who don't qualify for traditional Medicaid.

What distinguishes Fidelis Care is their emphasis on social determinants of health through their Social Care Network, which connects members with resources for housing, food, transportation, and other non-medical needs. They provide multilingual support in English, Spanish, Russian, and Chinese, reflecting their diverse membership base in New York. The company offers integrated member portals for bill payment, ID card access, and benefit management, as well as separate provider portals for healthcare professionals.

Fidelis Care is a legitimate, state-regulated health insurance company, not a payday alternative or consumer finance product. It serves primarily low-to-moderate income individuals through government-sponsored programs (Medicaid, Essential Plan, Child Health Plus) and marketplace plans. The main caveat is that enrollment depends on eligibility criteria specific to each plan type—Medicaid plans require income/asset qualification, while QHP plans require New York residency and enrollment during open enrollment periods or qualifying life events.

Services & Features

24/7 telemedicine services
Child Health Plus coverage
Fidelis Care at Home (managed long-term care)
Medicaid Managed Care plans
Medicare Advantage plans with supplemental benefits
New York Essential Plan ($0 premium)
Pharmacy benefit services and mail order programs
Provider network access and directory tools
Qualified Health Plans (ACA marketplace)
Social Care Network (housing, food, transportation resources)
WellCare Medicare and dual eligible plans
Wellness rewards and fitness reimbursement programs

Feature Checklist

Mobile App
Online Portal
Score Tracking
Credit Education
Personal Advisor
Identity Theft Protection

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • $0 premium Essential Plan available for eligible New Yorkers
  • 24/7 telemedicine with $0 copay on Qualified Health Plans
  • Comprehensive social care network addressing housing, food, and transportation needs
  • Multilingual support in English, Spanish, Russian, and Chinese
  • Integrated online member portal with bill payment and ID card access
  • No-cost preventive care and dental/vision coverage on multiple plan types
  • Medicare Advantage plans with supplemental dental, vision, and hearing benefits

Cons

  • Limited to New York state for most plan types; geographic restrictions apply
  • Enrollment dependent on eligibility criteria that exclude many consumers
  • No coverage available outside of enrollment periods without qualifying life events
  • Website does not clearly communicate plan costs, deductibles, or out-of-pocket maximums upfront

Rating Breakdown

Value
5.0
Effectiveness
3.7
Customer Service
3.7
Transparency
4.0
Ease of Use
4.2

Frequently Asked Questions

What services does Fidelis Catholic offer?

Fidelis Catholic offers 12 services including Medicaid Managed Care plans, New York Essential Plan ($0 premium), Child Health Plus coverage, Qualified Health Plans (ACA marketplace), Medicare Advantage plans with supplemental benefits, and 7 more.

Who is Fidelis Catholic best suited for?

Fidelis Catholic is best suited for Low-income New York residents eligible for Medicaid Managed Care or Essential Plan, Medicare beneficiaries seeking comprehensive Advantage plans with supplemental benefits, Families with children seeking affordable coverage through Child Health Plus or Qualified Health Plans, Individuals with chronic conditions needing coordinated care and social support services.

What are the strengths and weaknesses of Fidelis Catholic?

Key strengths: $0 premium Essential Plan available for eligible New Yorkers; 24/7 telemedicine with $0 copay on Qualified Health Plans; Comprehensive social care network addressing housing, food, and transportation needs. Areas to consider: Limited to New York state for most plan types; geographic restrictions apply; Enrollment dependent on eligibility criteria that exclude many consumers.

How does Fidelis Catholic compare to similar companies?

In the Insurance & Protection category, comparable providers include Allied, Laughlin Inc, One Source Financial, Inc.. Each company has different strengths — compare services, pricing, and consumer complaint records to find the best fit.

Quick Facts

Founded
1954
Headquarters
,
BBB Accredited
No
Certifications
NCUA Insured Charter #9810
Visit Fidelis Catholic

CreditDoc Diagnosis

Doctor's Verdict on Fidelis Catholic

Fidelis Care is appropriate only for individuals who are eligible for and actively enrolling in health insurance plans—primarily New York residents qualifying for Medicaid, Essential Plan, or ACA marketplace coverage. This company should not have been categorized as a "payday-alternative" and does not serve consumers seeking emergency cash, credit access, or debt solutions; it is a regulated health insurance provider addressing medical coverage needs, not financial services.

Best For

  • Low-income New York residents eligible for Medicaid Managed Care or Essential Plan
  • Medicare beneficiaries seeking comprehensive Advantage plans with supplemental benefits
  • Families with children seeking affordable coverage through Child Health Plus or Qualified Health Plans
  • Individuals with chronic conditions needing coordinated care and social support services
Updated 2026-05-08

Similar Companies

Allied logo

Allied

Allied Benefit Systems is a national healthcare solutions company providing self-insured health plan administration, compliance services, and care management for employers and groups.

4.2/5
BBB:

Best for: Mid-to-large employers seeking customized self-insured health benefit administration and compliance support, Organizations prioritizing data analytics and detailed reporting to manage healthcare costs and employee outcomes

Laughlin Inc logo

Laughlin Inc

Philadelphia-based notary and registration agency offering auto tag services, title processing, and notary services since 1989. Also provides insurance products through partner providers.

4.4/5
BBB: NR

Best for: Philadelphia-area residents needing auto registration, title work, and notary services in one visit, New Pennsylvania residents purchasing vehicles seeking quick title registration and transfer

One Source Financial, Inc. logo

One Source Financial, Inc.

One Source Financial, Inc. is a black-owned financial services company based in Jersey City offering insurance products and financial protection solutions.

4.4/5
BBB: NR

Best for: Consumers seeking to support black-owned financial service businesses, Jersey City and surrounding area residents preferring local financial services

Is Fidelis Catholic Right for You?

Answer 3 quick questions to see if this provider matches your needs.

1. What's your primary financial goal?

Financial Wellness Guides

Affiliate Disclosure: CreditDoc may earn a commission when you click links to Fidelis Catholic and other services. These commissions help us maintain our free research. Our editorial team independently evaluates all services. Compensation does not influence our ratings or rankings. Learn more.